Mentoring can involve coaching but not otherwise

Mentoring and coaching can be the best tools to help employees and organizations stay on top of their game. Studies have shown that both mentoring and coaching can have a positive impact on employees and organizations. With mentoring, you, as a company, can reap double benefits as it involves the development of both future leaders and current leaders (mentors), and it can increase staff retention by 40% over a period of five years. 

On the other hand, with coaching, you can boost personal confidence and self-esteem (most important to 79% of respondents) and work-life balance (76%) of employees, as per a study.

If you are wondering what mentoring and coaching are? No worries, as we've got you covered. Mentoring is a more informal relationship between a mentor and mentee, where the mentor provides suggestions, guidance, and motivation to the mentee. Coaching, on the other hand, is a more structured process with clearly defined aims and goals. The coach focuses on helping the individual reach their goals by providing tools and strategies that help them gain accountability.

With these in perspective, in this blog, we shall try to understand the difference between both, and how mentoring can emerge as a better choice when it comes to the overall development of employees.

How does mentoring work and its purpose?

Purpose of Mentoring

Mentoring is a process of helping an individual to develop their skills, knowledge, and attributes under the supervision and support of someone with more experience. A mentor can help with different areas of development, such as career planning, or they can provide better insights to ease workload.

The mentoring relationship is built on trust and mutual respect and should be confidential. The mentee should feel free to discuss any issues or concerns freely with their mentor, without fear of judgment.

A mentor can provide valuable resources and networks that the mentee might not otherwise have access to. They can also offer impartial opinions and smart recommendations, which can be invaluable for making difficult decisions.

Also Read: Upgrade your workplace with different mentoring programs

How does coaching work and its purpose?

Purpose of Coaching

In business, coaching is a process that helps individuals identify their goals and create action plans to achieve them. The coach also provides support and encourages you along the way to accomplish those certain sets of goals.

Mentoring can be superior to coaching in several ways in different circumstances. First, mentoring relationships are usually more traditional, with an experienced individual passing on knowledge and wisdom to a less experienced protégé. Second, mentoring is often more focused on career development, while coaching can focus on a particular aspect of a problem or daily work life. Finally, mentoring relationships tend to be of longer-term, while coaching typically has a more defined beginning and end.

That said, there is some overlap between the two approaches. Both involve helping someone else reach their potential and climb new heights.

Can mixing mentoring with coaching be beneficial?

Mentoring and coaching are two distinct approaches to helping employees learn and grow, and they are often combined in modern organizations. 

Mentoring involves a mentor providing tricks of the business and feedback to a mentee, while coaching focuses on helping the coach to identify and achieve their targets.

The strategy of mixing mentoring and coaching can be beneficial. To elaborate, a mentor is like a guiding principle and a coach is like a teacher. A mentor can suggest employees to learn something new, based on their experience, while a coach can give step-by-step instruction to learn or improve an employee's performance in their current role or teach them a particular skill. Both, the mentor and coach act as a team player to help the coachee or mentee learn new things and reach their goals.

For example, a successful salesperson who is mentoring a new salesperson can teach them the roles of the job, while a coach can help the new salesperson develop their particular skill set and help them stick to a daily plan that will maximize their results.

However, there can also be some negative effects when mentoring and coaching are mixed. For example, if a mentor is giving too much advice or if a coach is following a plan that's too strict, it can be hard for employees to figure out the best way to solve their own problem. Furthermore, if the roles of the mentor and coach are not clearly defined, it can lead to confusion and delay the progress.

For these reasons, it is important to ensure that mentoring and coaching are properly defined and combined in a way that will maximize their effectiveness. This means clearly outlining the roles and responsibilities of the mentor and coach, setting clear expectations for both parties, and providing adequate support and feedback.

Why is mentoring better for employees from an overall development perspective?

When it comes to employee development, mentoring has been shown to be more effective than coaching for the following reasons.

Holistic Approach

Mentoring provides employees with an advocate who can help them navigate the workplace, identify opportunities for growth, and build relationships. 

Coaching, on the other hand, is focused on individual performance and development. Also, while coaching can be beneficial for developing specific skill sets, it doesn't provide the same holistic support that mentoring does.

Building Confidence

Mentors can help employees feel more confident in their abilities by providing encouragement and positive reinforcement. They can also help employees develop a broader perspective of the organization and their place within it. This can motivate employees to take on new challenges and grow their skills.

Coaching often takes a more directive approach, providing employees with specific instructions on what they need to do to improve. Furthermore, this approach is limited to address specific areas of development for coachee.

Building Relationships

Mentors can help employees build relationships by serving as trusted advisors and sounding boards. They can provide employees with professional and personal support, offering advice and guidance on a variety of topics. This type of relationship-building is essential for developing a strong sense of community within an organization.

Thus, equipped with advice on how to build strong relationships, mentored employees have better relationships with their supervisors. They also feel more supported in their career.  

Also, when it comes to working relationship development, coaching generally has a more limited scope, focusing on professional development within the confines of an existing role or goals set by an employer. While coaching can certainly help employees develop working relationships, this is not one of its primary purposes.

Mentoring Helps Employees Develop Soft Skills

Mentoring helps employees develop the soft skills that are essential to succeed in today’s competitive world. Development of skills like communication, critical thinking, problem-solving, and leadership is possible through mentoring while coaching may not always provide the same level of opportunity.

Mentoring can Take Many Different Forms

Mentoring is versatile in nature as it can be formal, like a structured program with specific outcomes and it can be informal, like a more casual relationship between two people who share knowledge and experience. 

Mentoring Fosters Long-Term Development

Mentoring isn’t a one-time thing. It’s an ongoing relationship, which means that employees can continue to develop and grow over time. By establishing a mentoring relationship, employees have access to a wealth of knowledge and experience that they can use to further their own development.

Mentoring Is Crucial for Employee Retention

Mentoring is also a great way to ensure that your employees remain loyal to your organization. These programs help reduce employee turnover, keeps employees engaged and maintains the company culture. 

Mentoring Is Cost-Effective

Mentoring relationships don't have to be confined to a specific setting; they can be formal, like in the office, or informal, in any environment where the mentor and mentee are comfortable, therefore it wouldn’t be wrong to say that mentoring is cost-effective. 

For example, a colleague can act as a mentor when someone comes to them or shares their problems. This not only keeps them motivated towards work but they’ll experience a personal touch which will override any sense of problem that appears in the work front. This way, companies can inhibit a mentoring culture within their organization without spending much on hiring people externally. Whereas, coaching requires that a coach should have excelled in a particular skill set. 

Also Read: How to Set Mentorship Goals for Your Mentee?


Mentoring Programs in workplace

Mentoring is typically more focused on providing an understanding of work processes associated with a company's objectives, while coaching is more focused on helping someone achieve certain specific goals. 

Importantly, if you are someone looking out for the overall development of employees in terms of ongoing updation of skills and knowledge, then mentoring may be a better option.

You can also try mentoring platforms such as Mentoring Complete to match mentors with mentees within the organization. So, get ready to take your mentoring relationship to the next level!

Want to make your executive mentoring program successful? We're happy to help you!


Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What are the benefits of having a mentor?

There are many benefits to having a mentor, including receiving guidance and support from someone with more experience, gaining access to new opportunities, and developing new skills.

Q. What are the benefits of having a coach?

The benefits of having a coach include receiving support and motivation to reach specific goals, improving performance in specific areas, and gaining new insights.

Q. What is the difference between mentoring and coaching?

Mentoring is a process whereby an experienced individual provides guidance, support, and insight about work to another person. Coaching, on the other hand, is a process whereby an individual helps another person to attain a specific goal.

Q. What is the difference between mentoring and coaching?

There are many ways to find a mentor, including asking someone you admire for advice, seeking out professionals in your field, or joining a mentorship program.

Topics: Coaching and Mentoring, Coaching and mentoring difference, Benefits of coaching and mentoring, Difference between mentoring and coaching, Importance of coaching and mentoring, Mentoring can involve coaching but not otherwise